One Call
Multiple quotes from top-rated carriers
Since 2011
Locally owned in Lafayette, Indiana
4.9 ★
Average rating from our clients on Google
Every Year
Coverage check-up for every client
Why independent matters
One local agency, many insurance companies
When you call a captive agent, you get one company’s price. When you call Lafayette Insurance, you get choices.
Every insurance company is good at some things and not as competitive at others. One carrier may have the best rate for a young driver, another may love newer homes, and another may specialize in farms, mobile homes or commercial trucks. As an independent agency, we know where each company shines, and we put that knowledge to work for you.
We gather your information once, quote the carriers that fit your situation, and lay the options out side by side in plain English. If your rates climb at renewal, we can shop your coverage again without you starting over. And because we’re local, you have one team to call for questions, changes and claims, no matter which company insures you.
Lafayette Insurance
Independent agency representing multiple top-rated carriers
- Office: 3111 Builder Dr., Suite 6
Lafayette, IN 47909 - Call/Text765-474-2300
- Hours: Mon–Thu 9 a.m.–5 p.m.
Fri 9 a.m.–4 p.m.
Sat–Sun closed - Lines: Personal · Commercial · Farm · Life
Our carriers
Companies we represent
Here are some of the insurance companies we work with, and the coverage each one is best known for.
Featured
ERIE Insurance
A Fortune 500 insurer founded in 1925 and known for outstanding service, ERIE Rate Lock® auto policies, Guaranteed Replacement Cost on eligible homes, business packages and Erie Family Life coverage.
Auto
Home
Life
Business
Featured
Progressive
The nation’s largest auto insurer and No. 1 in commercial auto and motorcycle insurance, with Snapshot® savings and Progressive Home coverage that bundles with your auto.
Auto
Home
Toys
Commercial auto
Featured
Nationwide
A FORTUNE 100 company founded in 1926, Nationwide offers home, auto and other personal coverage.
Home
Auto
GEICO
A Berkshire Hathaway company and one of the largest auto insurers in the country, GEICO gives our clients another highly competitive option when we shop their auto coverage.
Auto
Motorcycle
AAA
One of the best-known names for drivers and families in America, AAA gives our clients another strong option for auto, home and umbrella coverage when we shop and bundle their policies.
Auto
Home
Umbrella
National General
An Allstate company offering auto, home, condo, renters, RV, motorcycle and umbrella coverage, plus commercial vehicle insurance. A strong option for drivers and homes that need flexibility.
Auto
Home
RV
Motorcycle
Openly
Premium homeowners insurance sold only through independent agents, with high-limit guaranteed replacement cost options and optional coverages like water backup and equipment breakdown. Great for higher-value homes.
Home
High-value homes
Foremost
Part of Farmers Insurance and a specialty insurer since 1952, Foremost covers mobile and manufactured homes, landlord and rental homes, RVs, motorcycles, boats and collectible autos.
Mobile homes
Landlord
RV
Specialty
Hagerty
A specialty insurer for classic, antique and collector vehicles, Hagerty covers collector cars, modern enthusiast cars, vintage motorcycles and campers, and collector tractors at an agreed value.
Classic cars
Collector vehicles
Agreed value
Universal Property
Universal Property & Casualty Insurance Company offers homeowners, condo, renters and landlord coverage, giving us another property option to compare for your home.
Home
Condo
Renters
Landlord
BHHC
Berkshire Hathaway Homestate Companies, part of the Berkshire Hathaway Insurance Group, writes workers’ compensation, commercial property and commercial auto coverage for businesses.
Workers’ comp
Commercial property
Commercial auto
USLI
USLI writes specialty and small business coverage, giving our business clients another company to compare.
General liability
Small business
Specialty coverage
Trexis
Trexis Insurance writes personal auto insurance. It is one more option we can review when other companies are not the right fit.
Personal auto
Bristol West
Bristol West, a Farmers Insurance company, writes personal auto insurance and gives drivers another option to compare.
Personal auto
We also work with additional specialty and commercial markets for hard-to-place risks. Carrier availability depends on your location, the type of coverage and underwriting.
Find your fit
Which company is right for you?
There’s no single best insurance company, only the best fit for you. Here’s where we often start for common needs.
🏠
Home & auto bundles
ERIE, Progressive, Nationwide, AAA and National General all offer multi-policy savings when you bundle your home and auto.
🏡
Higher-value homes
Openly, ERIE and Nationwide are strong choices when you need higher limits and broad replacement cost protection.
🚜
Farms & acreage
ERIE and National General offer farm programs built for working farms, hobby farms and the buildings and equipment that go with them.
🚗
Auto shoppers
ERIE, Progressive, GEICO, AAA, Nationwide and National General give us plenty of ways to find a competitive auto rate.
🏘️
Mobile homes, rentals & toys
Foremost specializes in manufactured homes, landlord coverage and recreational vehicles, with Progressive and Universal Property as other options. For classic and collector cars, Hagerty offers agreed value coverage.
🚚
Business & commercial auto
Progressive, ERIE and BHHC give us strong options for commercial auto, business packages, property and workers’ comp.
Every situation is different. We’ll recommend carriers based on your actual details, not a one-size-fits-all list.
How it works
Compare insurance companies in three easy steps
Tell us once
Call or text 765-474-2300, stop by, or request a quote online. We gather your details one time.
We shop the market
A licensed agent quotes the carriers that fit your situation and compares coverage, not just price.
Choose with confidence
We review your options side by side, answer every question and handle the switch for you.
Ready to see what your options look like?
One call to Lafayette Insurance puts multiple top-rated insurance companies to work for you.
Prefer to talk? Call or text 765-474-2300.
Areas we serve
Independent insurance across Greater Lafayette
Most of our clients live and work in Tippecanoe County and the surrounding area, but we help Indiana families, farms and businesses wherever they are.
- Lafayette
- West Lafayette
- Tippecanoe County
- Purdue University area
- Battle Ground
- Dayton
- Otterbein
- Brookston
- Delphi
- Attica
- Frankfort
- Monticello
FAQ
Independent agency questions, answered
What is an independent insurance agency?
An independent agency is appointed with several insurance companies instead of just one. That lets us compare carriers for you and recommend the coverage that fits best, rather than selling a single company’s products.
Does it cost more to use an independent agent?
No. We don’t charge you a fee to quote or compare coverage. You get local advice and multiple options at no extra cost.
Can I have policies with different companies?
Yes. Sometimes the best value is your auto with one company and your home or business with another. We’ll show you when bundling saves more and when splitting makes sense.
What happens if my rates go up at renewal?
Give us a call. We review renewals and can shop your coverage with our other carriers to see if there’s a better option, without you having to start over.
Who do I call if I have a claim?
Call us first at 765-474-2300. We’ll help you report the claim to your insurance company, explain what to expect and follow up for you.
Lafayette Insurance is an independent insurance agency located at 3111 Builder Dr., Suite 6, Lafayette, IN 47909. Company names, products and marks referenced on this page are the property of their respective owners. Listing a company does not imply that it endorses Lafayette Insurance. ERIE® and ERIE Rate Lock® are marks of Erie Indemnity Company; Progressive® and Snapshot® are marks of Progressive Casualty Insurance Company; Nationwide and the Nationwide N and Eagle are service marks of Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company; GEICO is a registered service mark of Government Employees Insurance Company; AAA is a registered trademark of the American Automobile Association, Inc.; Hagerty is a registered trademark of The Hagerty Group, LLC.
Carrier availability, coverages and discounts vary by state, product and underwriting, and are subject to policy terms, conditions, limitations and exclusions. Rankings and company facts are as reported by each company. Talk with a Lafayette Insurance agent for details.
