Independent agency since 2011 · 3111 Builder Dr, Ste 6, Lafayette, IN

Mon–Thu 9–5 · Fri 9–4 · Call or text 765-474-2300

Landlord Insurance: Single Family, Duplex, or Multi-Unit Complex Rental Properties

Get rental property insurance today with a landlord rental insurance policy today. Have multiple units? Personal or commercial, we can help.

  • 4.9 stars from 127 Google reviews
  • Independent since 2011
Brick and yellow duplex rental home

Landlord Insurance – Rental Property Insurance

Your rental dwelling portfolio with Lafayette Insurance

Your real estate investments come with unique challenges. Lafayette Insurance will take the time to learn your portfolio and help you select personalized coverage to protect you. Get rental property insurance with a landlord insurance policy today!

Prefer to talk? Call or text 765-474-2300.

Landlord Insurance in Lafayette and West Lafayette

With Purdue students, young professionals and families all looking for places to rent, many people in Greater Lafayette own a rental home, a duplex or a few doors. A standard homeowners policy is built for a home you live in, and it may not cover a property you rent out. Landlord insurance, often written as a dwelling fire policy, is designed for rental properties and the risks that come with them.

What landlord insurance covers

  • The dwelling – the house or building itself against covered losses like fire, wind, hail and the other perils listed in your policy
  • Other structures – detached garages, sheds and fences on the property
  • Loss of rental income – rent you lose while the property is being repaired after a covered loss
  • Landlord liability – protection if a tenant or guest is injured and claims you were responsible
  • Landlord-owned contents – appliances, furniture and supplies you provide in the rental

Your tenants’ belongings are not covered by your policy. Encourage, or require, your tenants to carry renters insurance. It protects their property and their liability, and it can reduce disputes after a loss.

Choosing the right type of policy

Dwelling policies come in several forms. Basic forms cover a short list of named perils and usually pay actual cash value. Broader forms cover more types of losses and can pay replacement cost. The right choice depends on the age and condition of the property, your mortgage requirements and how much risk you want to keep. We’ll explain the differences in plain English and compare several companies for you.

Many landlords also add an umbrella policy for extra liability protection. If you own several properties or hold them in an LLC, ask us about options built for that, including commercial property and general liability coverage.

Landlord insurance FAQs

Can I keep my homeowners policy if I move out and rent my house?

Usually not. Once you move out and rent the home to someone else, you’ll typically need a landlord or dwelling policy instead. Let us know before your tenant moves in so there’s no gap in coverage.

Do I need different coverage for a short-term rental?

Short-term rentals, like homes listed on vacation rental sites, are treated differently by many companies. Tell us how you rent the property and we’ll find coverage that fits.

Call or text 765-474-2300 with the property address, year built and how it’s rented, and we’ll compare options for you.

What sets our landlord insurance companies apart

Companies we represent for landlord insurance include ERIE, Openly, Universal Property and Foremost. Each one has its own strengths, and these are some of the options available through them:

  • Short-term rentals: Liability and furnishings coverage can be extended when you rent through platforms like Airbnb or Vrbo.
  • Lost rent: For rented condos, lost rental income can be paid for up to 24 months while a covered loss is repaired.
  • Condo units rented to tenants: Endorsements are available to keep a condo owner’s coverage working while the unit is regularly rented to tenants.

Features, limits and availability vary by company and policy. Ask us which options fit you.

Our process

Compare Quotes from Lafayette Insurance

01. Provide Details

Tell us a little bit about what you are wanting to insure.

02. Discuss Coverages

We educate you on insurance coverages relevant to you.

03. Compare Quotes

We shop multiple companies to find the best rates and protection.

04. Pick Your Policy

Choose the insurance plan that works best for your individual needs.

Lafayette Insurance Reviews

What our Clients Say

★★★★★

Joe and his staff are top notch. I never worry if I have an issue involving insurance. They are there to help make the experience worry free and professional. It’s worth your time to give Lafayette Insurance a call.

Stacey Minier

★★★★★

Tremendous support from Joe Couch. He was readily-accessible, diligent, and a tremendous help through the process of switching policies. Would recommend to everyone.

Daniel Layman

★★★★★

Joe Sr. and Jr. are both professional and do the very best they can to get you the best deal possible. They have reached out to me to let me know of opportunities to decrease my rates before my terms were up so I could plan accordingly. They always answer when I text or call with a problem. Can’t say enough good things about this company or the people running it!

Jon Chapin

★★★★★

Very professional and responsive. After calling several agencies in the area, our quote was 15% lower than anywhere else!

Devon Moore

★★★★★

Joe Jr. looks out for you. Initially he had me with one insurance agency. 1 year in and upon finding a new deal, he contacted me, helped me save some money, and found a more reliant insurance company for my family’s vehicles. He is personable and offers good advice without trying to overexert influence. I have not had to deal with a wreck yet and working through a claim, but I will update this post if it happens.

Isaac Schumacher

★★★★★

They are very nice and will find the best deal for you. They also follow up with you in the future to better you in better insurance for less.

Jasen Shaver

Read more client reviews →

Licensed advisors that care about our clients

Our average client review is 4.9 of 5 Stars

We represent some of the top insurance companies

Affordable rates and quality service

Ready to compare quotes and save?

One call, many insurance companies. We’ll shop your coverage and show you the best options side by side.

Call Get a Free Quote