Independent agency since 2011 · 3111 Builder Dr, Ste 6, Lafayette, IN

Mon–Thu 9–5 · Fri 9–4 · Call or text 765-474-2300

Progressive Insurance in Lafayette, IN, with a Local Agent in Your Corner

Progressive quotes from Lafayette Insurance, your local independent agent in Lafayette, IN. Auto, home, motorcycle, RV & commercial. Call 765-474-2300.

  • 4.9 stars from 127 Google reviews
  • Independent since 2011
Insurance agent with a clipboard shaking hands with a customer next to a damaged car

No. 1

Auto insurer in the U.S.*

A+

Financial strength rating from A.M. Best

No. 1

Commercial auto insurer*

Since 1937

Nearly 90 years of insuring Americans

Your local Progressive agent

A Progressive insurance agent in Lafayette and West Lafayette

You probably know Progressive from TV. What many people don’t know is that you can buy and manage a Progressive policy through a local, independent agent, and in Lafayette that includes us.

Progressive was founded in 1937 and is headquartered in the Cleveland, Ohio area. Today it insures more than 38 million policies, ranks as the largest private passenger auto insurer in the country, and leads the nation in commercial auto and motorcycle insurance. It’s known for innovation, from being the first major auto insurer to sell policies online to pioneering usage-based pricing with Snapshot®.

Lafayette Insurance is not Progressive’s corporate office or call center. We’re an independent agency on Lafayette’s south side, appointed to quote, sell and service Progressive policies. Progressive is one of the largest carriers in our agency, and our licensed agents know its products, discounts and underwriting inside and out.

Because we’re independent, we don’t stop at one quote. We can put Progressive side by side with ERIE and other top-rated companies so you can see real choices, then help you pick the coverage that fits your life and your budget. One local team, many options, and someone to call when you need help.

Lafayette Insurance

Independent agency representing Progressive and other top-rated carriers

  • Office: 3111 Builder Dr., Suite 6
    Lafayette, IN 47909
  • Call/Text765-474-2300
  • Hours: Mon–Thu 9 a.m.–5 p.m.
    Fri 9 a.m.–4 p.m.
    Sat–Sun closed
  • Lines: Auto · Home · Toys · Commercial

Progressive coverage we write

Progressive insurance for everything you drive, ride and own

From your daily driver to your weekend toys and the trucks that keep your business moving, we can build a Progressive policy, or a bundle, that fits.

Progressive Auto Insurance

Snapshot® savings, accident forgiveness, a long list of discounts and 24/7 claims support from the nation’s largest auto insurer.

Auto insurance →

Progressive Home Insurance

Homeowners, condo, renters and manufactured home coverage, with bundle savings when you pair your home and auto.

Home insurance →

Motorcycle, Boat & RV

Coverage from the country’s No. 1 motorcycle insurer, plus boats, personal watercraft, motorhomes, travel trailers, ATVs and more.

Motorcycle insurance →

Progressive Commercial Auto

Business auto and truck coverage from the No. 1 commercial auto insurer, for everything from a single pickup to a fleet of semis.

Commercial auto →

Boat & PWC

Boats, pontoons and personal watercraft for the Wabash and Indiana’s lakes.

RV & Trailers

Motorhomes, campers and travel trailers, on the road or parked at camp.

Renters & Condo

Protect your belongings and liability, perfect for Purdue-area renters.

Classic Cars

Specialized coverage for collector and classic vehicles you love.

Trucking

Owner-operators, for-hire carriers and local haulers.

Progressive auto insurance

Why Lafayette drivers choose Progressive auto

Progressive built its reputation on smart pricing and plenty of ways to save. Here are some of the features and discounts our clients ask about most.

📱

Snapshot®

Progressive’s usage-based program personalizes your rate based on how you actually drive. Snapshot has logged more than 100 billion miles and delivered billions in driver discounts.

🛡️

Accident Forgiveness

Small claims under $500 won’t raise your rate, and after five years with Progressive, your rate won’t go up for any claim in most states.

💰

Stackable Discounts

Multi-policy, multi-car, continuous insurance, homeowner, pay-in-full, automatic payment and paperless discounts can all help lower your premium.

🎓

Teen & Student Savings

Discounts for teen drivers, students with a B average or better, and college students who live away from home without a car.

🏆

Loyalty Rewards

The longer you stay, the more you earn, up to Progressive’s lifetime renewal guarantee after 20 years. Ask about the Deductible Savings Bank, too.

🚨

Roadside & Accident Response

Roadside assistance for tows, flat tires, fuel and lockouts, plus Accident Response, which can help connect you with a tow, emergency services and claims after a crash.

Coverages, discounts and programs vary by state and are subject to eligibility. We’ll walk you through exactly what applies to your Indiana policy.

Progressive home insurance

Home coverage that pairs perfectly with your auto

Progressive ranks among the top 15 homeowners insurance carriers in the country, with millions of property policies in force. For many of our clients, pairing a Progressive home policy with Progressive auto is one of the simplest ways to save.

  • Dwelling coverage to help repair or rebuild your home’s structure after a covered loss
  • Personal property coverage for your furniture, electronics, clothing and more
  • Loss of use coverage to help with living expenses if you can’t stay home during repairs
  • Personal liability protection for injuries or damage you’re responsible for
  • Optional endorsements for jewelry, art and other high-value items
  • Options for condos, renters and manufactured homes

Ask us about Progressive’s home discounts for quoting in advance, alarms and safety devices, and new home purchases, plus the multi-policy discount when you bundle.

Motorcycle, boat & RV

Insure your toys with the specialty leader

Whether you ride the back roads of Tippecanoe County, spend summer weekends on Lake Shafer or Lake Freeman, or hit the road in a motorhome, Progressive has been insuring recreational vehicles for decades.

  • No. 1 motorcycle insurer in the country, serving riders for more than 50 years
  • Insures more than 1.9 million boats and personal watercraft
  • A leader in RV coverage, from motorhomes to travel trailers
  • ATVs, UTVs, snowmobiles, golf carts and classic cars too
  • Multi-policy savings when you add toys to your auto policy
  • Motorcycles
  • Boats
  • Pontoons
  • Jet skis
  • Motorhomes
  • Travel trailers
  • ATVs & UTVs
  • Snowmobiles
  • Golf carts
  • Classic cars

Progressive commercial

Commercial auto from the No. 1 commercial auto insurer

Progressive insures more than 2.3 million commercial vehicles and has over 50 years of experience protecting the trucks, vans and cars that businesses depend on. We help Lafayette-area contractors, haulers and small businesses get the right coverage without the runaround.

  • Business auto for cars, pickups, vans, SUVs and trailers
  • Truck insurance for semis, dump trucks, tow trucks and box trucks
  • Fleet programs, including dashcam-based discounts in some states
  • General liability, business owners policies, workers’ compensation, professional liability and cyber coverage options
  • Pair with ERIE or other carriers for property and liability when that’s the better fit
  • Contractors
  • Landscapers
  • Plumbers & HVAC
  • Electricians
  • Food trucks
  • Tow operators
  • Delivery & courier
  • For-hire trucking
  • Farm & ag haulers

Awards & recognition

The strength behind your Progressive policy

Size, stability and a track record of innovation. Here’s why we’re proud to offer Progressive to our clients.

No. 1

Progressive is the largest private passenger auto insurer in the United States, insuring more than 37 million drivers.

Source: S&P Global Market Intelligence national written premium data, Q1 2026, as reported by Progressive

No. 1

Progressive is the country’s No. 1 commercial auto insurer and No. 1 commercial truck insurer, covering more than 2.3 million commercial vehicles.

Source: Progressive

No. 1

Progressive is the nation’s No. 1 motorcycle insurer and has been protecting riders for more than 50 years.

Source: Progressive

A+

Progressive has earned an A+ rating from A.M. Best, an independent measure of an insurer’s financial strength and ability to pay claims.

Source: A.M. Best, as reported by Progressive

No. 57

Progressive ranked No. 57 on the 2025 FORTUNE 500® list of America’s largest companies, with more than $75 billion in 2024 revenue.

Source: FORTUNE 500®, 2025, as reported by Progressive

$2.2B

Since 2009, Progressive’s Snapshot® program has delivered about $2.2 billion in discounts to drivers and logged more than 100 billion miles.

Source: Progressive

The Lafayette Insurance difference

Progressive’s protection, with a local team behind it

You could buy Progressive online. Here’s what you get when you buy it through Lafayette Insurance instead.

1

A real person who knows you

No call-center queues. Our licensed agents are right here on Builder Drive, a phone call or text away, and they know your policy.

2

More than one quote

We compare Progressive with ERIE and other top-rated carriers, so you see your real options side by side before you decide.

3

Help when you file a claim

Call us first. We’ll help you start your Progressive claim, explain what to expect and stay with you until it’s resolved.

4

A coverage check-up every year

We review your coverage at renewal so your policy keeps up with new vehicles, new drivers, new homes and new toys.

5

Every discount you’ve earned

We make sure the bundle, multi-car, student, homeowner and payment discounts you qualify for are actually on your policy.

6

Rated 4.9 stars by our clients

Our clients consistently praise our fast, accurate quotes and friendly coverage reviews. We’d love the chance to earn your review too.

Getting started

Get a Progressive quote in three easy steps

Reach out

Call or text 765-474-2300, stop by our office, or request a quote online.

We shop it for you

A licensed agent gathers your details, quotes Progressive and compares other carriers to find your best value.

Review & get covered

We walk you through every coverage, answer your questions, and handle the switch from your current insurer.

Looking for a Progressive agent near you?

Whether you’re new to Progressive or already a customer who wants a local agent, Lafayette Insurance is ready to help today.

Prefer to talk? Call or text 765-474-2300.

Areas we serve

Progressive insurance across Greater Lafayette

Most of our clients live and work in Tippecanoe County and the surrounding area, but we help Indiana drivers, families and businesses wherever they are.

FAQ

Progressive insurance questions, answered

Is Lafayette Insurance part of Progressive?

No. Lafayette Insurance is a locally owned, independent insurance agency. We’re appointed to sell and service Progressive policies, and we also represent ERIE and other top-rated insurance companies.

Why buy Progressive through a local agent instead of online?

You get a licensed local agent who knows your policy, compares Progressive with other carriers, makes sure you have every discount you qualify for, and helps you at claim time. You still get Progressive’s coverage, tools and 24/7 claims service.

What is Progressive Snapshot®?

Snapshot is Progressive’s usage-based program that personalizes your auto rate based on how you drive, using a mobile app or plug-in device. Safe driving can earn a discount, and we can help you decide whether it makes sense for you.

Does Progressive offer accident forgiveness?

Yes. Progressive won’t raise your rate for small claims under $500, and after five years with Progressive, your rate won’t go up for any claim in most states. Ask us how it applies to your Indiana policy.

Can you insure my motorcycle, boat or RV with Progressive?

Absolutely. Progressive is the country’s No. 1 motorcycle insurer and also covers boats, personal watercraft, motorhomes, travel trailers, ATVs, snowmobiles and more, often with multi-policy savings.

Do you only sell Progressive?

No. Progressive is one of the largest carriers in our agency, and we also represent ERIE Insurance and other top-rated companies. As an independent agency, we compare carriers so you get the right coverage at the best value.

Lafayette Insurance is an independent insurance agency located at 3111 Builder Dr., Suite 6, Lafayette, IN 47909, and is an appointed agent of Progressive. Lafayette Insurance is not Progressive and is not a Progressive corporate office. Progressive®, Snapshot® and related marks are trademarks of Progressive Casualty Insurance Company or its affiliates.

Coverages, features, discounts and programs described are subject to eligibility, underwriting, policy terms, conditions, limitations and exclusions, and vary by state. Progressive home insurance is provided and serviced by affiliated and third-party insurers, and some business coverages are provided through Progressive’s network of partner insurers. See the policy or talk with a Lafayette Insurance agent for details.

Rankings and statistics are as reported by Progressive. No. 1 auto insurer based on S&P Global Market Intelligence national written premium data for Q1 2026. FORTUNE 500® ranking based on 2024 revenue. Fortune and Fortune 500 are registered trademarks of Fortune Media IP Limited; Fortune and Fortune Media IP Limited are not affiliated with, and do not endorse the products or services of, Progressive or Lafayette Insurance.

Ready to compare quotes and save?

One call, many insurance companies. We’ll shop your coverage and show you the best options side by side.

Call Get a Free Quote